Kinda sorta yes but, not completely! I got Rimmel's Moisture Renew Lipstick in "Sunset" before MAC Viva Glam V in an attempt to save some bucks since I read a lot of reviews on how fantastic a dupe Sunset was. But, I ended up getting Viva Glam V anyways since, it does have a bit more of a pinky undertone compared to Sunset. And since I have pigmented lips, it does make quite a bit of a difference in the way it looks on me. Even if your lips are not so pigmented, you can still see a very subtle difference but, it's that pink in Viva Glam V that makes it look slightly better against my skin tone.
What do you think of these lipsticks? Dupe or no? Which one do you prefer?